EACC to appeal MP Oscar Sudi acquittal in certificate forgery case
Kapseret MP Oscar Sudi during a past court appearance. PHOTO | COURTESY
Audio By Vocalize
The Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission
(EACC) now plans to appeal the acquittal of Kapseret MP Oscar Sudi by the High
Court in case where he was accused of forging academic documents.
The
MP was facing charges of making a false declaration to the Independent
Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) during the 2013 General Election and
forging a Diploma Certificate in Business Management from the Kenya Institute
of Management (KIM) as well as a KCSE certificate after he claimed to have sat
for the exam at Highway Secondary School in Nairobi.
The
court on June 7, 2024 acquitted the lawmaker saying the prosecution had failed
to prove its case, adding it also produced no formal documents to back up the
allegations against him.
It
also noted that the manner in which the investigation was conducted was
irregular since the Investigating Officer carried out interrogations in a
hotel.
In
a letter to Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Renson Ingonga on Tuesday,
the commission wants the court to reopen the case citing three grounds of
dissatisfaction including prejudicial investigative lapses, lack of
critical exhibits, and the venue of recording statements.
On
the first ground, EACC faults the court for throwing out the case owing to the
fact that the prosecution obtained the evidence illegally and without notifying
the MP, contrary to stipulations of the law.
The
anti-graft agency argues that contrary to the court judgement, the
investigation officer obtained the evidence from Sudi even before he was
declared an accused person in the case, and that the MP had also recorded a
statement confirming his academic credentials to the IEBC.
“At
the time of the taking of the statement, and receiving the documents from the
accused, he had neither been charged in any court of law nor a decision to
charge him reached. In essence, he was not an accused person,” a source at EACC
told Citizen Digital.
“Secondly,
the accused recorded a plain statement which confirmed that he had the
qualifications that he had indicated in his self-declaration form submitted to
the IEBC on 30th January 2013 for purposes of the General Elections held on 4th
March 2013.”
The
source added: “Pursuant to the consent issued by DPP vide a letter dated 13th
July 2016 to charge Oscar Sudi, Chief Inspector Fredrick Muchugia Mwangi
recorded Oscar Sudi's charge and cautionary statement on 5th October 2016 upon
his arrest and before his arraignment in court on 6th October 2016.”
The
commission went on to note that the court also erred in stating that the
prosecution did not present formal and certified academic documents as verified
by the IEBC.
The
EACC disputed the ruling noting that the electoral body does not produced of
any of the said documents.
“IEBC
is not the maker of any of these documents i.e. KCSE certificate, School
Leaving Certificate, and KIM Diploma certificate. The IEBC received copies from
the accused person for purposes of complying with the rules for the nomination
of candidates to contest an election,” the source added.
“The
court, therefore, erred in ruling that IEBC should have certified the impugned
certificates. By making this ruling midstream during the testimony of the
Investigating Officer and disallowing production, the court effectively locked
out exhibits that were central to the case and then proceeded to make a finding
that the Investigating Officer did not produce the documents.”
Regarding
the manner of interrogations where the court faulted the place where the
statement was recorded, EACC says the court made the ruling without pointing
out evidence of irregularity or impropriety.


Join the Discussion
Share your perspective with the Citizen Digital community.
No comments yet
This discussion is waiting for your voice. Be the first to share your thoughts!