EACC seeks Ksh.40.3M refund from ex-KeRRA deputy director over forged degree
Image of the EACC headquarters at Integrity Centre in Nairobi. PHOTO | COURTESY
Audio By Vocalize
In a suit filed at the High Court's Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Division in Nairobi, the commission wants Margaret Wanja Muthui ordered to refund Ksh.40,329,379.65 in salaries and allowances earned during her employment at KeRRA between October 2009 and May 2023.
The commission is also seeking court declarations that her appointments as procurement officer and later procurement manager were fraudulent and illegal, arguing that the disputed academic qualifications formed the basis of her recruitment and career progression.
According to court documents seen by Citizen Digital, Muthui applied for the position of procurement officer in May 2009, presenting a curriculum vitae indicating that she held a Bachelor of Science degree in Computer Science from Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology (JKUAT).
She was subsequently hired with effect from October 7, 2009, before being promoted to senior procurement officer and acting procurement manager in September 2011.
The EACC says she again presented the same qualification, alongside a Master of Science degree in Procurement and Logistics, when applying for the position of procurement manager in November 2013. She was appointed to the position in June 2015, which was later reclassified as deputy director in charge of supply chain management.
The alleged irregularities came to light during an exercise to authenticate academic certificates following a Public Service Commission circular issued in June 2022.
KeRRA forwarded employees' academic certificates to JKUAT for verification, with the university subsequently informing the roads authority that Muthui's Bachelor of Science degree certificate was neither genuine nor issued by the institution.
The university reiterated the findings in a subsequent communication to the EACC in September 2023, according to the court filing.
Following her suspension in March 2023, Muthui denied possessing the disputed JKUAT degree in her response to KeRRA.
Instead, she presented a Bachelor of Business Administration degree in Procurement and Supply Chain Management, allegedly awarded by Kenya Methodist University (KeMU) in July 2008, together with a letter purportedly signed by the university's Registrar of Academic Affairs.
However, the commission says investigations established that Muthui had never enrolled at KeMU and that the degree certificate was not genuine.
It further alleges that the letter she submitted was not signed by the registrar, Dr. Lucy Ikiara, whose signature did not match the one on the document.
The EACC also questioned information in her academic records regarding her secondary education, saying its investigations established that she sat her Kenya Certificate of Secondary Education examination in 1995 and attained a mean grade of C, contrary to the B- grade indicated in her curriculum vitae.
Although JKUAT confirmed that it had awarded Muthui a Master's degree in Procurement and Logistics in 2012, the university's Senate approved its withdrawal during a meeting held on March 2, 2023, after establishing that the bachelor's degree she used to secure admission was not genuine.
KeRRA subsequently dismissed her on May 23, 2023, following disciplinary proceedings in which the board found her culpable of forgery and presenting false documents, among other charges.
The EACC now argues that the Ksh.40.3 million paid to Muthui during her tenure constituted proceeds of corruption or money related to corruption, contending that she should not benefit from employment allegedly obtained through fraudulent means.
The commission wants the court to declare her appointments null and void, order the recovery of the entire amount, and award interest at court rates from the dates the payments were received until settlement, alongside legal costs.
Muthui is yet to file her response to the claim in Civil Suit.

Join the Discussion
Share your perspective with the Citizen Digital community.
No comments yet
This discussion is waiting for your voice. Be the first to share your thoughts!