Court stops JSC from releasing judges and judicial officers' performance records
Chief Justice Martha Koome, chairperson of Judicial Service Commission. Photo: JSC/X
Audio By Vocalize
Justice David Mburu issued the conservatory orders restraining the JSC from releasing the disputed data either as an appendix, addendum or through any other section of the report.
The orders came after the court certified as urgent an application filed by Duncan Kariuki, who sought to challenge the planned release of the information scheduled for Friday, November 20.
Kariuki argued that the intended disclosure was being pursued without a clear legal, regulatory or policy framework outlining how individual performance information for judicial officers should be published.
He also raised concerns over the credibility of the data, questioning whether it had undergone independent verification to establish its accuracy and reliability.
In his application, Kariuki pointed out that a related matter filed on July 14, 2026, was still pending before the court. He argued that proceeding with the publication before the determination of the case could undermine the ongoing proceedings and render the application and petition pointless.
The applicant further maintained that the respondents should not proceed with the exercise while constitutional and legal questions surrounding the proposed disclosure remained unresolved.
In granting the interim orders, Justice Mburu noted that the application and the pending petition raised significant constitutional and legal issues that required judicial consideration.
The judge observed that publishing the contested information before the dispute was heard could effectively render the pending proceedings academic, prompting the court to intervene through conservatory orders.
The court directed the respondents and interested parties to file and serve their responses within seven days of being served with the application. Parties were also allowed to submit skeleton arguments.
The matter is scheduled for mention on December 1, 2026, when the court will issue further directions.

Join the Discussion
Share your perspective with the Citizen Digital community.
No comments yet
This discussion is waiting for your voice. Be the first to share your thoughts!