ODPP seeks to withdraw Solai Dam case after parties agree on out-of-court settlement

Under a Certificate of Urgency, the ODPP said that the victims and those accused had reached an out of court settlement where families who lost adults will get Ksh.1.2m from the owner and Ksh.800,000 each for those who lost children. 

This emerged during the ongoing trial where Solai Farm Perry Manusukh and eight others were charged with 48 counts of manslaughter on the May 18, 2018 and failing to prepare an environmental impact assessment report.

The other eight are Vinoj Jaya Kumar, Johnson Njuguna, Luka Kipyegen, Winnie Muthoni, Jacinta Were, Tomkin Odo Odhiambo, Williec Omondi and Lynette Cheruiyot.

Through State Counsel Alex Muteti, the ODPP sought to have the criminal case withdrawn though the court had already put the nine accused on their defense.

Muteti told Naivasha Chief Magistrate Nathan Lutta that the victims and the accused through their advocates had held several meetings where the issue of compensation had been arrived at.

While calling on the court to consider the application, he noted that the case had taken over six years, emotionally and financially draining all the parties involved.

“The victims in a letter to the ODPP requested that the matter be resolved out of court and after reviewing the case, we support alternative dispute resolution mechanisms,” he said.

Muteti told the court that under the agreement, the victims would be compensated through cash while withdrawing the criminal and civil case facing Manusukh.

“The victims and the owner of Solai farm have had a good working and living relationship and they want to maintain this even after the case,” he said.

Advocate Ferdinand Masinde told the court that they supported the application by the ODPP adding that all the affected victims had signed the agreement.

He added that the farm owner had already opened an account and deposited the required compensation escrow-cash to show his commitment in resolving the issue out of court.

Lawyer Hagai Chimei, who is representing the victims supported the petition to withdraw the case adding that all parties had agreed to the out of court settlement.

The magistrate will give his ruling on November 23.